Westminster, CO
A bathroom floor in a Denver home with the old toilet removed, showing the closet flange, a tape measure checking the rough in, a new wax ring and supply line, and a new comfort height toilet ready to set.
Plumbing Blog

Should You Repair or Replace Your Toilet?

Trevor Harvey

Key takeaways

  • Toilet work is part of [our full range of Denver plumbing services](/plumbing/denver-co).
  • It rocks, or the floor around it feels soft
  • Book [toilet repair or replacement in Denver](/plumbing/sink-faucet-toilet-replacement-repair/denver-co) with Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing or call (720) 964-1646.
  • Repair it when one part has failed and the porcelain is sound.

Part of our guide to Whole Home Plumbing Care.our full range of Denver plumbing services

What it is

Repair or replace a toilet. Repair a toilet when one part has failed, like a flapper, fill valve, or handle. Replace it when the tank or bowl is cracked, it rocks on a soft floor, it needs two flushes to clear, or you have rebuilt the inside more than once. Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing checks the flange either way.

Most toilet problems are small parts. Replacing a whole toilet for a worn flapper wastes money, and repairing a cracked one wastes a visit.

Toilet work is part of our full range of Denver plumbing services. Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing has repaired and replaced toilets in Denver homes since 2006. This guide shows which problems are worth repairing, when replacement is the smarter spend, and what a proper install includes.

Which toilet problems call for repair and which call for replacement?

Match what you see to the row below. Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing uses the same logic on Denver toilet calls.

Toilet repair vs replacement by symptom for Denver homes, from Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing
SymptomUsuallyWhy
Runs or refills on its ownRepairA worn flapper or fill valve is the usual cause
Handle loose or flush weakRepairChain, handle, or flush valve parts are replaceable
Leak at the baseRepair the sealA failed wax ring or low flange gets reset, not caulked over
Needs two flushes to clearDiagnose, then often replaceRule out a clog first, then an older bowl is the issue
Crack in the tank or bowlReplaceA crack cannot be repaired reliably
Rocks, or the floor around it is softReplace and repair the flangeMovement breaks the seal and may mean a long slow leak
Rebuilt the inside more than onceReplaceParts keep failing on an aging fixture

When is a toilet worth repairing?

A toilet is worth repairing when the porcelain is sound and one part has failed. A worn flapper, a misadjusted fill valve, a loose handle, or a failed wax ring are all repairs. Most running toilets are solved by replacing the flapper and adjusting the fill valve. The toilet itself can keep working for years. Our toilet repair and replacement in Denver service handles flappers, fill valves, handles, and wax ring resets.

A running toilet is worth fixing quickly because it wastes water every hour it runs. Our guide to the most common plumbing problems covers how to spot it early, and our toilet running constantly page walks through the fix.

When should you replace a toilet instead?

Replace a toilet when it rocks or the floor around it is soft, when the tank or bowl is cracked, when it needs two flushes to clear, or when you have rebuilt the inside more than once. Replacement also makes sense when you want comfort height or a modern low flow model.

  • It rocks, or the floor around it feels soft
  • There is a crack in the tank or bowl
  • It needs two flushes to clear on a regular basis
  • You have rebuilt the internals more than once
  • You want comfort height or a modern low flow model

When the answer is replace, our toilet installation and replacement service measures the rough in, checks the flange, and hauls the old toilet away.

Why does the flange matter when you replace a toilet?

The flange matters because the toilet seals against it with a wax or waxless ring. If the flange sits below the finished floor, is cracked, or has pulled its bolts out of the subfloor, a new toilet will seep no matter how good it is. Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing repairs or replaces the flange before the new toilet goes on.

Rough in matters too. It is the distance from the finished wall to the center of the closet bolts. Most toilets are built for a 12 inch rough in. Many older Denver homes use 10 or 14 inches instead, so we measure before a new toilet is ordered.

Can you fix a toilet yourself?

You can fix some toilet problems yourself. Swapping a flapper on a running toilet with a working shutoff is a classic DIY repair. Clearing a simple clog with a plunger or toilet auger is too. Call a plumber when the base leaks, the toilet rocks, the shutoff will not close, or other drains back up at the same time.

For a clog, our guide on how to use a toilet snake walks through the safe steps. If the same toilet clogs again and again, read why a toilet keeps clogging before you replace it. Our guide to DIY plumbing vs hiring a professional explains which toilet jobs fit each side. Toilet will not flush at all? Start with our toilet will not flush page. If several drains back up at once, roots in the main line are a common cause, and our guide to rooter service cost in Denver explains that call.

What does a new toilet installation include?

A proper toilet installation includes more than setting a new bowl. Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing measures the rough in, removes the old toilet, checks and repairs the flange, installs a new seal, bolts, and supply line, then levels, secures, and flush tests the new toilet.

  • Rough in measurement before ordering
  • Old toilet removed, wax residue cleaned, flange inspected
  • Flange repair, extender, or replacement where the height is wrong
  • New wax or waxless seal, new closet bolts, and a new supply line
  • New angle stop if the old shutoff will not seal
  • Level, secure, caulked, and flush tested

What to expect when you hire Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing

When you hire Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing to repair or replace a toilet in the Denver metro, the visit follows five steps. You get a plain answer on repair versus replacement and see the price before work starts.

  1. Diagnose: we find what failed and check the floor and flange
  2. Recommend: you get a straight answer on repair or replacement
  3. Quote: you approve the scope and price before we start
  4. Repair or install: we fix the part, or set the new toilet on a solid flange
  5. Test: we run several flush tests and check for leaks at the base and supply
  • Service area: Denver, Westminster, Arvada, Broomfield, Thornton, Lakewood, and the wider metro
  • Toilets: standard, comfort height, and one piece models installed
  • Licensing: Colorado Master Plumber MP-00189274 and Colorado State Plumbing Contractor 2110
  • Experience: family owned and serving Denver homes since 2006

Ready for a new toilet? Book toilet installation in Denver and we will get it set right the first time.

Frequently asked questions

Talk To A Plumber

We reply fast. Same day when possible.

First Name
Last Name
Email
Phone Number
How did you hear about us?
What services are you interested in?
Message

More on whole home plumbing care

This guide is part of our whole home plumbing care cluster. Start with our full range of Denver plumbing services, then read the guides below for the detail behind each decision.

Need A Plumber In The Denver Metro?

Family owned since 2006. Licensed Colorado Master Plumbers, answering 24/7.