DIY Plumbing vs. Professional Services: What’s More Cost-Effective?

Trevor Harvey • September 22, 2025

When annoying issues like leaky faucets, clogged drains, or running toilets pop up, homeowners are usually faced with a critical decision. Do you call a professional plumber for help? Or do you fix it yourself? At first glance, the do-it-yourself route may seem like the less expensive option. But is it really more cost-effective in the long run? Taking a deep dive into the true costs of DIY plumbing vs. hiring a professional plumber in Westminster, Colorado, will show you that there’s more than money to consider – like time, tools, expertise, and risk. 



The Case for DIY Plumbing

The most obvious appeal of DIY plumbing is saving money on labor. Professional plumbers typically charge $50 to $150 per hour, with some services requiring a minimum service call fee – even for small fixes. If you can tackle a plumbing problem on your own, you may only need to buy parts, which can significantly cut down your expenses. In cases like replacing a showerhead or replacing a toilet flapper, DIY can be a very cost-effective solution. 


Thanks to YouTube, blogs, and other step-by-step guides, even plumbing novices have access to a vast array of instructional content. With a little research and patience, many homeowners can get some basic plumbing skills into their arsenal. These skills can save money over time an increase your confidence in performing home maintenance. When you’re facing an overflowing toilet or a dripping pipe at midnight, it’s not always convenient to wait for a plumber to show up. Emergency services also come with a premium. Handling the issue yourself – even as a temporary fix – can prevent additional damage until a professional arrives. 


Hidden Costs & Risks of DIY Plumbing

While the do-it-yourself route can offer quick savings, it’s important to consider the potential downsides that may make it more expensive in the long run. Plumbing systems are more complex than they seem. Pipes are often hidden behind walls or under floors, and modern plumbing incorporates codes and safety standards. A seemingly simple mistake – like failing to properly seal a connection or overtightening a fitting – can lead to water leaks, mold growth, water damage to flooring or drywall, or voided warranties on appliances. These issues usually result in costly repairs, far exceeding what it would have cost to hire a professional initially. 


Professional plumbers already own specialized tools like basin wrenches, pipe cutters, inspection cameras, or plumbing torches. If you’re tackling a more advanced job, you may need to invest in these tools, which could amount to hundreds of dollars for a single repair. Even renting equipment can add up quickly and offset the cost advantage of doing it yourself. 


Time is money, and there is a time commitment to doing it yourself. A job that takes you all weekend may have taken only an hour for the plumber. Not to mention the trips you had to make to the hardware store. If you take time off work or delay other responsibilities, your time investment could outweigh any savings. In some regions, plumbing work must be done by a licensed professional to meet local building codes. DIY work done improperly can lead fines, issues when selling your home, or insurance problems if a water-related claim is filed. This is a serious risk that many homeowners overlook when deciding to DIY.


The Case for Hiring a Professional Plumber

Licensed plumbers are trainted to quickly diagnose issues and fix them efficiently. They’ve seen hundreds of scenarios and can often spot underlying problems that DIYers might miss. For example, a homeowner could unclog a drain without realize tree roots are invading the sewer line. Replacing a faucet might seem simple, but an expert could detect corrosion or low water pressure that signals a larger issue. This proactive diagnosis can save significant money down the road. 

Most professional plumbers offer warranties on parts and labor, giving you added peace of mind. If something goes wrong after the repair, they’ll often come back to fix it at no extra charge. They also carry liability insurance, which protects you from costs in case of damage to your property during the repair. This level of protection is simply not available with DIY work. Professional plumbers also have access to commercial-grade materials and fixtures not available at big box stores. These components typically last longer and perform better, meaning fewer repairs or replacements in the future. 


When to DIY & When to Call a Pro

How do you decide when to roll up your sleeves or pick up the phone and call in a professional? For the DIYer, the tasks should be low-risk, visible fixes that don’t involve structural changes. Minor repairs like toilet flappers and faucet washers are typical do-it-yourself jobs, as are clogged drains that can be handled with a plunger or hand snake. Showerhead or aerator replacement is also a simple task that many DIYers can handle. 


Always call in a pro for serious problems like sewer line blockages or backflow. They should also be brought in if there is a burst pipe or major leak. If there is low water pressure affecting multiple fixtures, it could be a serious problem that requires professional expertise. Also avoid doing any water heater installations yourself. If the job requires permits or code compliance, it’s best to bring in the pros from the start so that the project is completed to compliance from start to finish. If you’re unsure, a quick phone consultation with a plumber can clarify whether the job is safe to do it yourself.


The Hybrid Approach: Combining Both Worlds

Not every plumbing decision has to be all-or-nothing. Many homeowners find the most cost-effective strategy is taking a hybrid approach by pulling a little from both sides. This involves handling what you can while knowing when to bring in the professionals. This method lets you maximize your savings without sacrificing safety, compliance, or long-term results. 

Start with basic troubleshooting. Before calling a plumber, use a plunger or drain snake for clogs. Tighten loose fittings and check for obvious leaks. Replace basic parts like faucet aerators or toilet fill valves. These steps can solve a lot of problems, or at least narrow down where the more serious issue may have originated. Know your limits. As soon as an issue goes beyond your comfort level or tools, stop and call a licensed plumber. Delaying help can increase damage and ultimately cost you more. 


When a plumber visits, don’t be afraid to ask questions. Many professionals are happy to explain what they’re doing, what caused the issue, and how to prevent it in the future. You might even pick up some tips that will help you out in future DIY projects. Even if you handle everyday issues, it’s also wise to schedule periodic checkups. This is especially true for your water heater, outdoor plumbing before winter, sewer line inspections, and pressure testing for leak detection. Routine maintenance can catch problems early and extend the life of your plumbing system. 


Long-Term Value & Peace of Mind

There’s a psychological value in knowing the job was done right. Hiring a pro eliminates second-guessing and gives you a clear path for accountability if something goes wrong later. Additionally, professionally maintained plumbing systems can increase your home’s resale value and appeal. Home inspectors look closely at plumbing, and signs of DIY work that doesn’t meet code can deter buyers or reduce your asking price. 


Final Verdict: What’s More Cost-Effective?

DIY plumbing can be cost effective for small, simple jobs where the risk is low and your confidence is high. It’s a great way to save money and learn useful home maintenance skills. However, for anything that is complex, hidden, or potentially destructive, professional plumbing services offer far better value in the long run. They may cost more upfront, but the expertise, efficiency, and protection they provide often prevent far greater expenses due to mistakes, damage, or legal issues. 

Big problems are for the pros, while quick fixes and small leaks are usually DIY. Of course, the do-it-yourself method should only be done if you’re comfortable performing the task. If you’re somewhat handy, the hybrid approach can give you the best of both worlds. It will teach you to handle small problems efficiently while building a trusted relationship with a plumbing professional you can rely on when it matters most. 


Doing What’s Right for Your Home

Plumbing is one of those things where doing it right matters more than doing it cheap. While the appeal of saving money with the do-it-yourself method is understandable, the potential for costly mistakes can outweigh the benefits – especially for jobs that impact your home’s infrastructure. If you’re ever in doubt, don’t hesitate to get a quote from a licensed plumber before starting the work yourself. It could end up being the most cost-effective decision you make. For more information on when you should take the DIY route or to figure out if you’re in over your head, reach out to the experts at Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing today.

The Afford-a-Rooter Plumbing Repair Guarantee

24/7 Immediate Response

Certified Emergency Plumbing Service Professionals

Affordable, High-Quality Services

Recent Blog Post
By Trevor Harvey September 16, 2025
Sewage odors are usually a signal that something is going wrong with the plumbing in your home. Don’t hesitate to fix any of these problems, as they could be a serious issue.
By Trevor Harvey July 17, 2025
Plumbing issues can cause a lot of damage in a short period of time. Being prepared can make a world of difference.
By Trevor Harvey May 24, 2025
A backed-up sink can quickly move from being a minor inconvenience to a major headache. Whether it’s in your kitchen, bathroom, or utility room, there are signs that something isn’t quite right. It can lead to standing water in the basin, foul smells, and slow drainage. If it keeps happening, the backed-up sink can be more than just a nuisance, it can signal serious plumbing problems that require immediate attention. If you’re ever unsure about how to deal with a clogged sink, always call in a professional. Getting the correct diagnosis from the outset can save you time and money. There can be a number of reasons why the sink is getting backed up, and we’ll look at some of the most common culprits. Some of them may be minor issues, but some are also best dealt with by an experienced plumber in Westminster . Clogged Drain Pipes The most frequent cause of a backed-up sink is a clog somewhere in the drainpipe. In kitchens, food scraps, grease, coffee grounds, and soap scum are the primary reasons behind these clogs. In bathrooms, it’s usually hair, soap residue and toothpaste. This happens because, over time, debris builds up on the walls of your drainpipes. Eventually, this buildup becomes thick enough to partially or fully block water flow, causing slow drainage or a complete backup. There are a few steps you can take to fix clogged drain pipe. Try a plunger first. Make sure to create a seal over the drain and plunge firmly. If that doesn’t clear up the clog, use a drain snake or auger to physically break up and remove the clog. Avoid chemical drain cleaners. They can cause corrosion in the pipes and often provide only a temporary fix. Grease Buildup Grease can be a sneaky villain when it comes to your kitchen sink. It might go down the drain like a liquid, but it solidifies as it cools. That causes it to stick to your pipes, which can clog your drain. That sticky, solidified grease also latches on to other debris over time, making the clog even more difficult. It’s a good practice to simply never pour grease down the drain. Instead, let it cool and dispose of it in the trash. If you suspect that there is some grease buildup clogging up your sink, there are some steps you can take to try and clear it out. Pour a mixture of hot water and dish soap down the drain to break up the grease. For those that are stubborn, you can use a mixture of baking soda and vinegar and flush down with hot water. You can also consider installing a grease trap if this is a recurring issue. Blocked P-Trap The P-trap is the U-shaped pup under your sink. It’s shaped this way to hold a small amount of water within the pipe to block sewer gases from entering your home. However, because it’s shape, it makes it a common spot for clogs in your system. Most of the time, if your P-trap is clogged, you can unclog the blockage yourself with a little do-it-yourself work. If you want to attempt to clear out the P-trap yourself, the first thing you need to do is place a bucket underneath the P-trap itself. This will help catch any water or whatever is clogging the P-trap without making a mess. Unscrew the connectors on either side of the trap and remove it. Be careful, as there is always water in there, so make sure you do this over the bucket. Clean out any debris from inside the stretch of pipe of the P-trap and then reattach it. Test the sink to see if that’s where the only clog was. If it’s still running slowly or seems blocked, reach out to a professional for help. Vent Pipe Blockage Your plumbing system includes vent pipes that let air in and maintain the proper pressure. If a vent pipe becomes blocked by debris, leaves, or even the occasional birds next, it can prevent water from flowing freely. This can cause backups in your system that can appear like the drain is clogged. There are different signs of a vent blockage than your typical clogged pipe. One of the things you should notice are gurgling noises when water drains. If it seems like there are multiple fixtures that are draining slowly throughout the house, it could also be a sign of a vent blockage. Smells of sewer gas are also an indication that this is where the issue is coming from. Clearing a vent pipe typically requires going onto the roof, which may be best left to a professional plumber. They will inspect the vent stack and remove any obstructions. Main Drain Line Clog If multiple sinks or fixtures are backing up – especially in the lowest parts of your home – the issue may be a clog in your main sewer line. A common cause of these types of blockages comes from items flushed down the toilet that shouldn’t be – such as feminine products or wipes. Even if the wipes say they’re flushable, they’re not, so try and dispose of them properly in the trash. Tree roots like to invade the line, causing obstructions that lead to these backups, but they can also because by a pipe collapse or offset joints. This is a job for a professional. They have cameras and other tools that will inspect the line and other special tools to clear or repair the blockage. Garbage Disposal Malfunction If your kitchen sink backs up and you have a garbage disposal, the unit itself might be the issue. Clogs in the disposal – or just past it – are very common, especially if improper items have been stuck into the system. While the garbage disposal is a good tool for breaking up discarded food, it can cause a lot of problems. It’s important to use it in moderation by spacing out the food you put in it. Don’t put large amounts of food in the garbage disposal at one time, and try to not put fibrous vegetables in there, as well, since they can get wrapped around the blades. To fix your clogged garbage disposal, always make sure there is no power going to the disposal. The blades are sharp and dangerous, and you don’t want it to surprisingly turn on at the wrong moment. Never use your hands to remove visible debris. Always use tongs or pliers. You can manually turn the disposal blades using a hex key under the unit. If you cleared it out and it still doesn’t drain, disconnect the unit and call a professional. Troubleshooting Checklist Before calling a plumber, there are some things you can try to troubleshoot the issue. Always try to isolate the problem. Ask yourself if the issue is happening in just one sink or is it happening throughout the home. Also investigate if water is backing up from one sink into another – like the kitchen sink backing up into the laundry sink. Use your simple tools first. Plungers are a great first option, while drain snakes can get you into the pipe and often times to the source of the clog. Your wet/dry vacuum can also be used to dislodge a clog by sucking it out. Always avoid using harsh chemical drain cleaners as some of these can damage your pipes and usually don’t solve the underlying issue. Try natural solutions like baking soda and vinegar followed by boiling or hot water. When to Call the Professionals While minor clogs and backups can often be handled with do-it-yourself methods, there are definite indicators of when it’s time to call in the professionals for their expertise. If you’ve tried a number of times to unclog a sink and there are still frequent backups in that location, it’s probably time to give the pros a call. If there is water backing up into multiple sinks, it’s probably an indicator of a larger issue, as are gurgling sounds and bubbling from drains. If you have a difficult clog that is associated with strong sewer odors or standing water that won’t drain after plunging, you probably need industrial-strength tools to take care of the issue. The best way to deal with a backed-up sink is to stop it from happening in the first place. A lot of times, being proactive can prevent you from having to make those calls to the professionals. Use sink strainers to catch food particles in the kitchen sink, and run hot water after each use to help flush the lines. In the bathroom, use hair catchers in drains and avoid flushing non-dissolvable items like wipes or cotton balls down your fixtures. Don’t ignore any warning signs like slow drains or strange smells. Clogged drains can be a pain in the neck, but they may also be an indicator of other issues. For more information on how to deal with clogged drains in your home, reach out to the experts at Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing today.
By Trevor Harvey April 29, 2025
Plumbing issues can arise at any time, often when you least expect them. Whether it’s a clogged drain, a leaking pipe, or low water pressure, plumbing problems can be frustrating and costly if left unaddressed. As a homeowner, understanding the most common plumbing problems and how to prevent them can save you time, money, and stress. At Afford a Rooter, we specialize in affordable plumbing in Denver, offering professional rooter, sewer, drain, and water line repair services. In this blog, we’ll go over some of the most frequent plumbing issues homeowners face and provide practical tips to help prevent them. 1. Clogged Drains and Toilets Why It Happens Clogged drains are one of the most common plumbing issues. They occur when substances like grease, soap scum, hair, food particles, or foreign objects build up inside the pipes, restricting water flow. Toilets can also get clogged when excessive toilet paper or non-flushable items (such as wipes, cotton balls, or hygiene products) are flushed. How to Prevent It Use drain strainers to catch hair, food debris, and other particles before they go down the drain. Avoid pouring grease or oil down the kitchen sink - it solidifies and clogs pipes. Flush only toilet paper and human waste - no wipes, cotton swabs, or other items. Regularly clean drains with baking soda and vinegar to break down buildup. When to Call a Plumber If you notice slow drainage, gurgling sounds, or standing water, a professional plumber can perform a drain cleaning service to remove tough clogs before they cause backups. 2. Leaky Faucets and Fixtures Why It Happens A leaky faucet might seem like a minor annoyance, but it can waste gallons of water over time and increase your water bill. Typically, leaks are caused by worn-out washers, seals, or corrosion inside the fixture. How to Prevent It Inspect faucets regularly for drips or leaks and replace worn-out washers promptly. Turn off faucets gently rather than forcing them closed. Invest in high-quality fixtures that are less prone to wear and tear. When to Call a Plumber If a simple washer replacement doesn’t fix the leak, it could indicate a more serious issue in the plumbing system. A plumber can diagnose the problem and recommend a long-term solution. 3. Low Water Pressure Why It Happens Low water pressure can make daily tasks like showering or washing dishes frustrating. It may be caused by mineral buildup in pipes, leaks, faulty fixtures, or municipal supply issues. How to Prevent It Clean aerators and showerheads regularly to remove mineral deposits. Check for hidden leaks - unexplained water stains or high water bills could indicate a leak. Replace old, corroded pipes if mineral buildup is restricting water flow. When to Call a Plumber If your water pressure suddenly drops or remains consistently low, a plumber can inspect your plumbing system to identify and resolve the issue. 4. Running Toilets Why It Happens A running toilet wastes a significant amount of water and can drive up your utility bill. Common causes include a faulty flapper valve, worn-out fill valve, or improperly adjusted float. How to Prevent It Replace the flapper valve when it starts to wear out. Check the float height and adjust it if the toilet runs continuously. Inspect the fill valve and replace it if water continues to flow into the tank. When to Call a Plumber If your toilet continues running despite replacing parts, a plumber can help identify deeper issues, such as sediment buildup or internal leaks. 5. Water Heater Issues Why It Happens Water heaters can develop issues like inconsistent temperatures, leaks, or complete failure over time. Sediment buildup, broken heating elements, or a faulty thermostat are common causes. How to Prevent It Flush the water heater tank annually to remove sediment buildup. Set the thermostat to 120°F to prevent overheating and improve efficiency. Inspect for leaks or rust - replace the unit if necessary. When to Call a Plumber If your water heater isn’t providing hot water or is making unusual noises, a professional plumber can diagnose whether it needs repair or replacement. 6. Burst Pipes and Leaks Why It Happens Frozen pipes, high water pressure, corrosion, and shifting foundations can all lead to burst pipes or leaks. A burst pipe can cause significant water damage if not addressed quickly. How to Prevent It Insulate exposed pipes during winter to prevent freezing. Monitor water pressure and install a pressure regulator if needed. Check for rust or corrosion on pipes and replace damaged sections promptly. When to Call a Plumber If you suspect a hidden leak or experience a sudden pipe burst, shut off the main water supply and call a plumber immediately. 7. Sewer Line Backups Why It Happens Sewer line blockages can result from tree root intrusion, grease buildup, or flushing non-biodegradable materials. A backed-up sewer line can lead to foul odors, slow drains, and potential health hazards. How to Prevent It Avoid flushing anything besides toilet paper and waste. Never pour grease down the drain - it solidifies and clogs sewer lines. Schedule regular sewer line inspections to detect potential issues early. When to Call a Plumber If multiple drains in your home are backing up, it could indicate a serious sewer line issue. Professional rooter services can clear blockages and prevent further damage. 8. Sump Pump Failure Why It Happens Sump pumps protect basements from flooding, but they can fail due to power outages, improper installation, or clogged discharge lines. How to Prevent It Test your sump pump regularly by pouring water into the pit and ensuring it activates. Keep the discharge line clear of debris and obstructions. Consider a battery backup to keep the pump running during power outages. When to Call a Plumber If your sump pump isn’t working properly, a plumber can repair or replace it to ensure your home stays dry. Conclusion Plumbing issues are an inevitable part of homeownership, but many common problems can be prevented with regular maintenance and awareness. By taking proactive steps—such as keeping drains clear, monitoring water pressure, and scheduling professional inspections—you can avoid costly repairs and maintain a reliable plumbing system. If you’re dealing with a stubborn clog, a running toilet, or a more serious plumbing emergency, Afford a Rooter offers affordable plumbing in Denver to help resolve the issue quickly and efficiently. Contact us today to schedule a service and keep your plumbing system in top shape!
By Trevor Harvey April 12, 2025
A little bit of preventative maintenance with your plumbing can really help save big bucks down the line.
Show More