Westminster, CO
A white toilet in a bright Denver bathroom with a closet auger and a flange plunger laid on a towel beside it, ready to clear a toilet that keeps clogging.
Plumbing Blog

Why Does My Toilet Keep Clogging?

Randy Johnson

Key takeaways

  • Repeat toilet clogs are a regular call for our [Denver rooter service](/rooter/denver-co).
  • Lift the tank lid and check that the flapper seals and the chain has a little slack
  • Stop using every toilet and drain in the house.
  • The usual causes are too much paper or wipes for the flush, a weak flush from low tank water or scaled jets, an object lodged in the trap, or a blockage in the branch or main line.

Part of our guide to Rooter and Toilet Clogs.Denver rooter service

What it is

A toilet that keeps clogging. A toilet that keeps clogging usually has one of four causes: more paper or wipes than the flush can carry, a weak flush, an object stuck in the trap, or a blockage past the toilet in the branch or main line. Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing finds which one before clearing it again.

Plunging treats the clog, not the cause. If the cause stays, the toilet clogs again, and a main line problem can turn into a sewage backup.

Repeat toilet clogs are a regular call for our Denver rooter service. Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing has cleared Denver toilets and sewer lines since 2006. This guide walks through the common causes, the clues that point to each one, and when it is time to call.

What makes a toilet clog over and over?

Start with the clue you notice most. These are the repeat clog causes Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing finds most often on Denver calls.

Common causes of a toilet that keeps clogging, the clue, and the usual fix, from Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing
CauseClueUsual fixDIY or pro
Wipes, hygiene products, or heavy paperClogs after certain usePlunge, then change what gets flushedDIY
Low water level in the tankWeak flush, water below the marked lineAdjust the fill valveDIY or pro
Scaled rim jets or siphon jetWeak swirl in hard waterClear or replace the fixturePro
Object lodged in the trapAuger comes back empty, clog returns fastAuger it out or pull the toiletPro
Older low flow bowlOften needs two flushesReplace the toiletPro
Branch or main line blockageTub or floor drain gurgles or backs up tooClear the line, then camera itPro

Why does my toilet clog so easily?

A toilet clogs easily when the flush does not have enough force for what goes into it. Wipes, hygiene products, and heavy paper loads catch in the trap. A tank that fills below its marked water line leaves too little water for a full flush. In hard water, scale can choke the rim jets and the siphon jet that drive the bowl.

  • Lift the tank lid and check that the flapper seals and the chain has a little slack
  • Confirm the tank fills to the marked water line
  • Look under the rim for crusted or blocked jets
  • Flush only toilet paper, and split heavy loads into two flushes

Can something stuck in the trap cause repeat clogs?

Yes. A toy, a brush head, or another hard object lodged in the trap lets water through but catches paper every time. The toilet clears, then clogs again within days. A closet auger sometimes hooks the object out. If it will not come, the toilet usually has to be pulled to retrieve it.

Our guide on how to use a toilet snake shows the safe way to try an auger first. If the auger comes back with nothing and the clog keeps returning, treat it as an object or a deeper problem and call.

When is a clogged toilet really a main line problem?

A clogged toilet is really a main line problem when other drains react to it. If a tub, shower, or floor drain gurgles or backs up when the toilet is flushed, the blockage sits past the toilet in the shared sewer line. Plunging the toilet cannot reach it. The line needs to be cleared and usually checked with a camera.

In older Denver homes with clay or cast iron sewer laterals, roots are a common reason a main line keeps backing up. Our page on multiple drains clogged at once explains what to do first. Our residential rooter service in Denver clears the main line and finds the cause.

Should you pour drain cleaner in a toilet that keeps clogging?

No. Most toilet clogs are dense paper, lodged objects, or blockages in the trapway. Those need pressure and mechanical reach, not chemicals. Some drain cleaner labels warn against use in toilets and against plunging afterward. A flange plunger or a closet auger is the safer first step.

Our post on whether Drano is safe on a toilet clog explains the label warnings in detail.

Is it time to replace a toilet that keeps clogging?

It may be time to replace a toilet that keeps clogging when the flush itself is the problem. Early 1990s low flow models earned a reputation for weak flushes, and a bowl that routinely needs two flushes to clear is a replacement sign. A modern toilet with a good flush rating clears waste without trouble.

Before replacing, rule out a blocked line. A new toilet on a clogged branch line still clogs. When the fixture is the cause, our toilet installation service measures the rough in and checks the flange before setting a new one.

How do you stop a toilet from clogging again?

To stop a toilet from clogging again, remove the cause, not just the clog. Keep wipes and hygiene products out of the bowl. Keep the tank filling to its line. Have a plumber pull any lodged object. If other drains are involved, get the main line cleared and checked so the backup does not return.

Wondering whether your drains need regular cleaning? Our guide on how often drains should be professionally cleaned explains when a schedule helps and when it does not.

What to expect when you hire Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing

When you hire Afford-A-Rooter Plumbing for a toilet that keeps clogging in the Denver metro, the visit follows five steps. You get the cause and the price before we start.

  1. Check the tank: flapper, chain, and water level
  2. Auger the trap and the branch drain to find what is catching
  3. Quote: you approve the scope and price before further work
  4. Camera the line when the clog returns or other fixtures are involved
  5. Fix the cause: replace worn tank parts, pull the toilet for an object, reset the flange, or clear the main line
  • Service area: Denver, Westminster, Arvada, Broomfield, Thornton, Lakewood, and the wider metro
  • Response: 24/7 emergency rooter service for main line backups
  • Licensing: Colorado Master Plumber MP-00189274 and Colorado State Plumbing Contractor 2110
  • Experience: family owned and serving Denver homes since 2006

Toilet clogging again? Book residential rooter service in Denver and we will find the cause.

Frequently asked questions

Talk To A Plumber

We reply fast. Same day when possible.

First Name
Last Name
Email
Phone Number
How did you hear about us?
What services are you interested in?
Message

More on rooter and toilet clogs

This guide is part of our rooter and toilet clogs cluster. Start with Denver rooter service, then read the guides below for the detail behind each decision.

Need A Plumber In The Denver Metro?

Family owned since 2006. Licensed Colorado Master Plumbers, answering 24/7.